Sharlie

Payette Lake’s mystery with a name from radio

What is Sharlie?

Sharlie is the lake monster of Payette Lake in McCall, Idaho: a local legend built around reported sightings of a large, unidentified shape in the water. The stories are part of Idaho folklore; no verified specimen establishes an unknown lake creature.

Reported sightings and the naming contest

Payette Lake’s modern monster legend became visible in August 1944, when the Payette Lakes Star reported residents watching a large unidentified creature in the lake. Early stories used names such as “Slimy Slim” and described a long moving form or wake. In September 1946, a group of witnesses reportedly watched an object or animal estimated at several dozen feet long repeatedly surface and dive, adding another heavily repeated episode to the legend.

The name Sharlie arrived in 1954 through a contest run by A. Boone McCallum, editor of The Star-News. The winning suggestion played on a then-familiar radio catchphrase, “Vas you der, Sharlie?” Once the creature had a memorable name, it became increasingly embedded in McCall identity. Reports continued for decades, though descriptions varied and no definitive photograph or specimen emerged.

Possible explanations

Payette Lake supports large fish, floating timber, waves, wakes, and shifting light that can all produce unusual observations. No verified body or biological sample establishes a giant unknown animal. The McCall Public Library now preserves a 66-page Sharlie subject file beginning with material dated August 3, 1944, while the Idaho State Historical Society includes Sharlie in public programs about Idaho folklore. That archival and cultural record makes Sharlie a strong Legends & Lore subject regardless of zoological reality.

Evidence and claims

1940s newspaper reports, the 1954 naming contest, archival subject files, and Sharlie’s place in Idaho folklore are documented. No verified specimen establishes an unknown Payette Lake species.

Sources

Visiting Payette Lake

You can explore the setting of the story from public lakeside parks in McCall. Legacy Park and Art Roberts Park offer beach access in town; Ponderosa State Park offers shoreline trails and day-use areas. Check the official park information for current access, fees, and seasonal conditions before you go.

For another strange stop on your trip, browse Idaho oddities. To explore more creature stories, visit the cryptids archive.